Recently, there was a report that Marvel was negotiating with Chris Evans about the possibility of reprising the role of Steve Rogers. Evans himself was quick to assure fans that it was just a rumor, but sparked an argument among the MCU fanbase as to whether or not such a return might work.
Obviously Steve’s arc ended in Avengers Endgame, and Evans stood his ground in that moment when it would be his last outing as Cap. And the forcefulness of that ending must remain intact. But there are a couple of ways to make it work without tarnishing Endgamelegacy.
10 I shouldn’t bring it back – Steve’s dance with Peggy was the perfect ending for the character
When audiences first met Chris Evans’ Steve Rogers, he was a soldier who would do anything to win World War II, even crash a plane full of weapons of mass destruction on ice. But by then, he had also fallen in love with Peggy Carter and made a date with her. When she woke up 80 years later, all she could focus on was missing that dance.
Throughout the Infinity Saga, he refocused his efforts on being a soldier, leading the Avengers in and out of battles against robots and aliens. After defeating Thanos, he finally felt comfortable hanging up the shield and went back in time to live a full and happy life with Peggy. His dance in the final scene of Endgame it was the perfect ending for the character.
9 How It Could Work: Tutoring The Falcon And The Winter Soldier
It seems unlikely that the elderly and widowed Steve Rogers gave Sam Wilson his shield and then never spoke to his two best friends again. Steve will surely be Sam’s mentor as he takes up his mantle, and Bucky too, as he continues to try to undo his brainwashing.
Chances are high that Steve will appear in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, cheering them on and guiding them on their way to becoming a well-oiled crime-fighting duo.
8 Shouldn’t Bring It Back: The MCU Should Avoid Holding On To The Past
There have been rumors of “Marvel fatigue” for a few years, and the MCU has been able to avoid it by keeping things fresh with movies like Thor: Ragnarok Y Black Panther, but as you move towards aEndgame world, Marvel needs to put the past behind us or it will become a real risk.
Star Wars‘the inability to let go of the past has held him back – The awakening of the force, Rogue oneY Single they were all inextricably linked with nostalgia to the original 1977 movie, and if Marvel holds onto retired characters like Iron Man and Captain America, then that fatigue might finally set in.
7 How it could work: show up in flashbacks
With rumors of Robert Downey, Jr. appearing on Black widow – which will take place between Civil war Y Infinity war – maybe the way for Chris Evans to return as Steve Rogers is in flashback sequences to preserve the ending of his story.
If Marvel continues to set movies across the entire timeline of history, then they can bring back the younger versions of many beloved characters, such as the ’90s era. Captain Marvel and his aging agents of SHIELD
6 I shouldn’t bring it back: the Infinity saga was the story of the original six, the new saga belongs to the new avengers
The first three phases of the MCU comprise “the Infinity Saga,” which told the story of the original six Avengers who came together to protect Earth from otherworldly threats, culminating in their epic fight against the Mad Titan. That story has been told and Marvel is moving into a new phase and, with it, a new saga.
The new saga belongs to the new Avengers. The original Avengers that appear in Phase Four, such as Black Widow, Thor, and Hawkeye, are passing the torch on to their successors. But Cap already did that in Endgame.
5 How it could work: parallel universes
While the latest MCU story arc revolved around the Infinity Stones, the new one is set to revolve around the multiverse.
Featuring Evan Peters Quicksilver appearing on WandaVision and all kinds of rumors about returning actors in Spider man 3It’s quite possible that Evans could perform an alternate version of Steve Rogers without tarnishing his original arc.
4 Shouldn’t Bring It Back: Marvel Can Never Get Over Cap’s “On Your Left” Moment
The pinnacle of Cap’s journey occurred on the battlefield in Avengers Endgame. As he prepared to face the armies of Thanos alone, Steve heard a familiar voice in his ear: “To your left.” Then Doctor Strange and Wong opened a bunch of portals to let the rest of the Avengers in to back him up.
Nothing will be able to top the triumph of this moment, and if Marvel can’t bring Evans back in a way that surpasses everything that came before, then they shouldn’t bring him back at all.
3 How It Could Work: A Unique Movie About The Return Of The Infinity Stones And The Red Skull Showdown
When the Hulk sent Cap back in time to return the Infinity Stones and he returned as an old man, the movie skipped a pretty incredible adventure through the Quantum Realm. Cap crossed space and time to return the Infinity Stones to their place. The Soul Stone belongs to Vormir, where the reincarnated Red Skull protects it.
Filling in this blank in the timeline would be an amazing standalone action game in which Steve Rogers goes to Asgard and Morag and finally takes on his arch enemy. The movie could end with Steve returning to make his date with Peggy.
2 I shouldn’t bring him back – he’s already handed over the shield to a new Captain America
While Thor has yet to hand over his powers to Jane Foster and Clint Barton has yet to train Kate Bishop to take over the Hawkeye mantle, Steve Rogers has already passed the shield on to a new Captain America.
Everything fans could wish for from Cap’s departure, including choosing his own replacement, was covered in Endgame. Bringing him back would be an exaggeration.
one How it could work: Old Steve could appear in every movie
Now that Stan Lee has sadly passed away and will no longer be able to appear in all Marvel movies, the new regular MCU cameo may be the elderly Steve Rogers seen at the end of Endgame.
Replacing Lee himself with one of his timeless creations might be a fitting way to honor his legacy, and it might also suggest that Steve is caring for the next generation of Avengers.
NEXT: MCU: 10 Most Exciting Things To Come In Phase Four
Star Wars: 5 Coolest Jedi Grand Masters on Canon (& 5 Who Didn’t Deserve Rank)
About the Author