Why Captain America’s shield is stronger in the comics than the MCU

Captain America’s shield is an iconic Marvel weapon, but in the MCU, Cap’s shield is nowhere near as strong as his comic book counterpart.

In the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Captain AmericaThe shield is an incredibly strong and durable weapon that is an efficient tool for defeating baddies across the board, but compared to the shield Cap wields in Marvel Comics, it doesn’t even compare to the original. And to think, it all comes down to what each shield is made of!

As synonymous with Captain America as Cap’s love for America and what its values ​​stand for, Cap’s shield is an object that hardly needs an introduction. Used as Cap’s primary weapon of choice dating back to his humble Marvel Comics beginnings during WWII, the red, white, and blue of his sequined shield is as much a part of who Captain America is as from his equally iconic outfit or from his favorite hobby of punching evil villains in the face.

Related: Marvel’s New Captain America Comic Slammed For Political Content

But compared to its MCU counterpart, the shield Captain America uses in the comics is much stronger for a few different reasons. Made entirely from a comic book-exclusive metal called proto-adamantium, the most obvious reason Cap’s shield is stronger than the one used in the MCU is simply what it’s made of. Comprised of, but not limited to, the metal known as vibranium, Cap’s comic shield, as the name suggests, also includes the nearly indestructible man-made metal known as adamantium; an alloy that is well known to fans of the adamantium-clawed hero, Wolverine, and that can withstand incredible amounts of force, temperatures, and energy blasts (among many other things).

Bucky Barnes, Sam Wilson and Steve Rogers charge up the evildoers.

In contrast, the MCU version of the shield is composed solely of vibranium, a special alloy that the people of Wakanda primarily find and use (including their protector, Black Panther), making it an extremely powerful weapon in its own right and somewhat. It is almost unrivaled. in the cinematic universe, but unfortunately not something that can go toe-to-toe with Cap’s comic weapon. Considering adamantium isn’t a thing in the movies (yet), Cap’s MCU shield is only made up of vibranium, giving the live-action version of the shield a noticeable drop in quality by default.

Known in the MCU for being smashed, cracked, and scratched by any number of characters, both heroic and villain, vibranium is a metal that is extremely powerful in its absorption and redirection of kinetic energy, but it can also be completely destroyed if directed enough power at any time. Meanwhile, and thanks to the unique proto-adamantium construction of Cap’s comic shield, this version of his weapon is completely resistant to any form of extreme temperatures, blunt attacks and, combined with the energy absorbing properties of its similar elements to vibranium, any kind. of kinetic assault that Cap can face while on the battlefield.

So while Captain America’s MCU shield is a powerful weapon in its own right, it simply can’t be compared to near perfection to his comic book shield which is not only non-recreated, but as strong as it is durable. This iconic shield may have recently passed a new Captain America in the movie universe, but he’ll always be the strongest in the comics … until a certain person with access to adamantium shows up, of course.

Next: Captain America and Hawkeye’s Comic Rivalry Belonged to the MCU

Laughing Batman and Robins

The darker version of Batman just returned to DC Comics

About the Author


Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *